Sound & Complete
(ppt):
|
19
| Quantifier Closure
| Φ ≡ QC(φ) ≡
∀M∃y∃∀x∀x'
[α(x')→φ]
|
| Truth/Valid:
|
| - M[a]⊧Φ
| Formula Φ is true under variable assignment a
in universe/model M.
|
| - ⊧Φ
| Φ is Valid, ie Φ is true under every model/ass
M[a].
|
| - Γ⊧Φ
| Φ is a Logical Consequence of Γ,
ie Γ→Φ is valid,
|
| |
ie Φ is true under every model/ass M[a]
under which Γ is true.
|
| Proofs:
|
| -
Γ⊢Φ
| Φ is a Theorem or Syntactic Consequence of
Γ,
ie from formulas in Axiomsfixed∪Γ,
one can prove Φ.
|
| -
(Φi-2∧Φi-1)
⇒Φi
| If φi-2 and φi-1
are lines in your proof, then you can add φi,
ie (Φi-2∧Φi-1)
→Φi can be proved.
|
| Interchangeable?
| ⊧, ⊢, ⇒, and
→ are interchangeable when interpreted with QC.
|
| | Be Careful. α(x)⇒∀x α(x)
even though α(x)→∀x α(x) is not true.
|
| Sound:
| A Proof System is Sound if
a proof of φ from Γ
ensures that Φ is valid when Γ is valid.
|
| - Traditionally
| Γ⊧φ ensures Γ⊢φ
|
| - Our proof system
| Γ⊧φ ensures Γ⊢QC(φ)
|
| - Rule Requires
| Rule "If φi-2 and φi-1
are line in your proof, then you can add φi"
|
| |
requires
"If QC(φ)i-2 and QC(φ)i-1
are valid, then so is QC(φ)i",
|
| |
ie
"Φi-2∧Φi-1⇒Φi",
requires
"Φi-2∧Φi-1→Φi".
|
| Complete
| A Proof system is Complete if
Φ being valid
ensures that it has a proof.
i.e. Γ⊢Φ ensures Γ⊧Φ
|
|